lead-nurturing

Is Your Lead Engagement Strategy Dying After Form Submission?

Charles Higgins

Charles Higgins

— 12 min read
Featured
Featured

Table of Contents

Introduction — Why This Matters

We recently created a short walkthrough with Andrew George that focuses on a simple but powerful truth: leads often go cold the moment they hit submit on a form. That drop-off is avoidable. In this post, we’ll walk through a practical, step-by-step approach for bringing lead engagement back to life using the automation features built into the platform we use for customer communications.

We’ll show how to trigger immediate outreach when a prospect completes a form, how to combine email and SMS for better reach, how to handle replies with branching logic, and how to escalate to voice actions like call connects and dropped voicemails. We’ll also provide templates, timing recommendations, and troubleshooting tips so you can implement these automations quickly and confidently.

What You’ll Learn

  • How to use a "form submitted" trigger to start automations automatically.
  • How to combine email and SMS to maximize response rates.
  • How to use a pre-built nurturing template to save time.
  • How to handle replies with positive and negative response paths.
  • How to reconnect with non-responders via call connect and voicemail drops.
  • Best practices for timing, personalization, and compliance.

Why Immediate Follow-Up Wins

When someone fills out a form, their interest is real and timely. The likelihood of conversion drops rapidly as time passes. That’s why having an automation that engages a lead immediately—and on multiple channels—is critical. We want to convert intent into conversation while interest is high. Doing this consistently saves time, prevents manual errors, and makes our sales process predictable.

Overview of the Workflow

The basic structure we recommend looks like this:

  1. Trigger: Form submitted
  2. Immediate Email and SMS sent to the new contact
  3. Wait for a reply
  4. If reply is positive → send booking link or route to salesperson
  5. If reply is negative → ask a short survey or request feedback
  6. If no reply after set time → call connect or drop voicemail + follow-up SMS

Step 1 — Create the Form and Define Intent

Before building automations, we design the form itself intentionally. A clean, purposeful form improves conversions and makes automation logic simpler.

Essentials for a high-converting form:

  • Limit required fields to only what’s needed—name, phone, and email are often enough for initial contact.
  • Include a brief line about what the lead will receive and the expected response time.
  • Use clear consent language that mentions they may receive messages by email and SMS, and how to opt out.
  • Tag the form submission with an identifier (for example: "Website Opt-In" or the specific campaign name) so we can segment later.

Once the form is published on the site or landing page, we’re ready to attach a workflow to the "form submitted" trigger.

Step 2 — Start with a Template (and Why We Like Them)

Templates accelerate setup and ensure best practices. We often start with a pre-built lead nurturing template—think of it like a “Fast Five” style sequence tailored for new leads. A good template gives us:

  • A proven cadence of messages across email and SMS
  • Branches for replies vs. no replies
  • Placeholders we can personalize quickly
  • Actions already wired for booking or escalation

We take the template and customize subject lines, message copy, and timing to match our offer and brand voice. If desired, we can also build the same set of actions from scratch—the logic remains the same.

Step 3 — Configure the Trigger: Form Submitted

The first move in our automation is straightforward: a "form submitted" trigger. When a contact submits the specific form we created, the workflow fires automatically.

Key points when setting the trigger:

  • Select the exact form you want associated with the automation (this prevents actions firing from unrelated forms).
  • Ensure the trigger only runs on new submissions (or configure to run for resubmissions if that suits your process).
  • Add an initial tag or custom field update so we can identify source and campaign later.

Step 4 — Immediate Outreach: Email + SMS

We send both an email and an SMS immediately after form submission. This multi-channel approach dramatically increases the chances we get a reply.

Why both channels?

  • Email provides context and longer copy for offers, links, and attachments.
  • SMS is immediate and has higher open and response rates—perfect for quick conversions and scheduling.

Sample email structure:

  • Subject: Clear, benefit-driven (e.g., "Your [resource/offer] — Next Steps")
  • Opening line: Thank them for submitting and set expectations (what they’ll receive and when).
  • Body: Short paragraph with the offer, a question that encourages reply (e.g., "What’s your biggest challenge right now?"), and a clear call to action.
  • Closing: Sign-off that includes the name of the team or person who will follow up.

Sample SMS copy (short and actionable):

  • “Hi [First Name], thanks for requesting [offer]. Quick question—are you looking to start this month or later? Reply 'Now' or 'Later' and we’ll set things up.”

We recommend asking a direct, reply-friendly question in both messages. A response creates a conversational thread that our automation can evaluate and route accordingly.

Step 5 — Wait for a Reply: Branching Based on Response

After the initial outreach, we pause to see whether the contact replies. This is where automation gets powerful—rather than a single path, we design branches:

Positive Replies

If the lead replies with a positive signal (interested, wants to book, asks for details), we route them down a conversion path:

  • Send an immediate confirmation message thanking them for the reply.
  • Include a direct booking link or automatically assign the lead to a salesperson for a call.
  • Update lead status and add a "hot lead" tag so sales can prioritize.

We prefer to automate the booking step whenever possible. An automated calendar link that integrates with the salesperson’s availability removes friction and converts interest into scheduled conversations.

Negative Replies

If the reply indicates lack of interest or a complaint (negative response), we pivot to feedback and qualification:

  • Send a brief message asking for a one-question survey—what stopped them from moving forward? (e.g., price, timing, lack of need)
  • Offer a helpful resource or suggest they keep in touch—this keeps the door open.
  • Tag the lead appropriately (e.g., "not interested", "future follow-up") so we can re-engage later with relevant content.

Turning negative replies into feedback is gold. We learn why leads aren’t converting and improve our messaging, pricing, or targeting over time.

Step 6 — No Reply? Escalate with Calls and Voicemails

Not every lead will reply to email or SMS. That’s expected. The difference between a dead lead and a converted lead is often a thoughtful follow-up. Here’s how we handle no-response paths:

  • Wait a set period (we commonly use 24–72 hours) after the initial messages before escalating.
  • Attempt a call connect action that routes the contact to a live salesperson's phone.
  • If the call goes to voicemail or is unanswered, use an automated voicemail drop to leave a pre-recorded message.
  • Follow the voicemail drop with another concise SMS that references the call and next steps.

Call connect helps us have real conversations with warm leads, while voicemail drops let us scale voice outreach without needing to make every call live. The combination keeps leads warm and increases appointment rates.

Tips for Effective Voicemail Drops

  • Keep it short—15–30 seconds is ideal.
  • Introduce who we are and why we called (refer to the form they completed).
  • Include a clear next step (e.g., "Reply 'CALL' to schedule a quick 10-minute chat").
  • Use a natural, friendly tone—don’t sound scripted.

Timing & Cadence: When to Send What

Cadence matters. Too many messages too soon is annoying. Too few, and we lose the moment. Here’s a tested cadence to start with, which we adjust based on results:

  1. Immediately (within 1–2 minutes): Send email + SMS
  2. 24–48 hours later: If no reply, follow up with a second SMS or short email
  3. 72 hours after submission: Attempt call connect and drop voicemail if unanswered
  4. 1 week later: Final follow-up sequence (email + SMS) offering resources or a "last chance" booking link

We always A/B test timing for our audience. Some industries favor same-day follow-ups; others respond better with a slightly longer cadence. Start with the above, measure, and iterate.

Personalization: Small Details, Big Impact

Personalization dramatically improves response rates. The platform supports tokens (like first name and campaign source), and we use them thoughtfully:

  • Use first name in the opening line of SMS and email.
  • Reference the specific offer or resource they requested.
  • If available, reference the company name or a relevant detail from the form.
  • Adjust tone depending on how they answered any qualification questions on the form.

We avoid over-personalizing with data we don’t have. Authenticity matters more than forced personalization.

Segmentation & Scoring: Prioritize High-Value Leads

Not all leads are equal. We add tags and update fields during the workflow to help sales prioritize:

  • Add tags like "new lead", "form: X", "campaign: Y", and "hot lead" based on replies.
  • Use simple scoring rules (e.g., +10 points for positive reply, +5 for booking link clicked) to sort leads by likelihood of conversion.
  • Create views or lists in your CRM based on score and tags to help reps focus on the highest priority opportunities first.

When a lead expresses interest, our goal is to move them toward a booked appointment quickly. We recommend these options:

  • Include a direct calendar link in the positive reply path so they can self-schedule.
  • Or, automatically assign the lead to an available salesperson and send a notification to that rep to call immediately.
  • Use booking pages that respect the salesperson’s availability and buffer times—this reduces no-shows.

Automated routing plus calendar links provide the frictionless experience prospects expect and minimize back-and-forth scheduling emails.

Using Surveys for Negative Responses

If a reply indicates the lead isn’t ready or isn't interested, a one-question survey can yield actionable insights:

  • Question examples: "What’s stopping you from moving forward—price, timing, not a fit, other?"
  • Keep it one or two quick responses (single-choice or short free text).
  • Use survey answers to update tags and to enroll the contact in a nurturing sequence tailored to their reason.

Even when a lead is not currently converting, capturing why helps us refine targeting and messaging—and often uncovers opportunities for future offers.

Testing and Quality Assurance

Before turning any workflow live, we test it thoroughly. A single missed token or broken link can turn a conversation cold.

Testing checklist:

  • Submit the form as a test contact and verify the email and SMS arrive as expected.
  • Test positive and negative reply paths by sending test responses and verifying the correct steps fire.
  • Test call connect and voicemail drops to ensure caller ID and message playback are correct.
  • Verify that tags, lead scores, and calendar links populate correctly in the CRM.
  • Confirm opt-out language and unsubscribe tools work per compliance rules.

Tracking Outcomes and Iteration

Automation is only as good as the data behind it. We track these metrics to measure performance and refine our approach:

  • Open and reply rates for email and SMS
  • Number of calls connected and voicemails dropped
  • Bookings created from the workflow
  • Conversion rates from submission to booked appointment
  • Survey feedback trends and common objections

Using regular review cycles—weekly for immediate campaigns and monthly for long-term trends—we iterate on copy, timing, and offerings to constantly improve conversion.

Compliance and Respectful Messaging

Respecting contact preferences and legal requirements is non-negotiable. We make sure every workflow includes:

  • Clear consent language on the form for email and SMS communications.
  • An easy opt-out method in every message (e.g., "Reply STOP to unsubscribe").
  • Careful handling of do-not-contact lists—automations must check these lists before sending any outreach.
  • Limited frequency to avoid overwhelming contacts and staying within local messaging regulations.

Following these rules reduces complaint rates and protects our sender reputation.

How This Saves Time and Reduces Headaches

We set up automations to handle routine touches—email, SMS, initial calls—so our team can focus on real conversations that convert. The benefits are practical and measurable:

  • Faster response times increase conversion likelihood.
  • Automated routing and calendar links reduce back-and-forth scheduling.
  • Voicemail drops let us scale voice outreach without tying up agents.
  • Tagging and scoring make prioritization simple and efficient for sales teams.
  • Automations reduce human error and provide consistent experience across all leads.

Real-World Example: A Simple "Fast Five" Variation

Here’s a condensed version of a practical sequence we use for new leads who request a consultation:

  1. Form Submitted → Trigger workflow
  2. Immediate Email: "Thanks—here's your resource + next steps" with a question prompting reply
  3. Immediate SMS: A short, conversational prompt asking for timing preferences
  4. Wait 48 hours → If no reply, send second SMS offering a booking link
  5. Wait 72 hours → Attempt call connect and drop a voicemail if unanswered
  6. Final follow-up email one week later with additional resources and a "last chance" booking link

This builds multiple touch points while keeping the cadence polite and purposeful.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

  • Sending only email: many leads respond faster to SMS or phone.
  • Over-automation: too many messages too fast turns people off.
  • Poor personalization: generic messages perform worse—use basic tokens and context.
  • Not testing: broken links, wrong tokens, or misrouted calls can kill conversions.
  • Ignoring feedback: negative replies are data—take action on what you learn.

Sample Message Templates We Use

Use these as starting points and adapt to your voice and offer.

Initial Email

Subject: Your [Offer/Resource] — Next Steps

Hi [First Name],

Thanks for requesting [offer]. We’ve sent your [resource/next steps]. Quick question—what’s the main result you’re hoping to achieve in the next 30 days? Reply and let us know so we can point you to the best next step.

Best,

[Team Name]

Initial SMS

Hi [First Name], thanks for requesting [offer]. Are you looking to start this month or later? Reply NOW or LATER and we’ll follow up with the best options.

Positive Reply Auto-Response

Thanks for the reply, [First Name]! You can book a short call here: [calendar link]. If you prefer, reply with a few times that work and we’ll schedule it for you.

Voicemail Drop Script (15–25 sec)

Hi [First Name], this is [Rep Name] from [Company]. We noticed you requested [offer]. I wanted to follow up personally—reply CALL to schedule a quick 10-minute chat or reply STOP to unsubscribe. Talk soon.

Testimonials and Social Proof

"We implemented this exact sequence and increased our booked appointments by 35% within the first month. The mixed-channel approach made getting conversations so much easier." — Marketing Lead
"Dropping a voicemail after two SMS attempts cut down time to first contact and helped our reps reach more qualified prospects without dialing manually." — Sales Manager

Conclusion — Bring Leads Back to Life

If we let leads go cold after they submit a form, we waste the value of our marketing. By using a "form submitted" trigger, sending both email and SMS, waiting for replies, and branching intelligently—plus escalating with call connect and voicemail where appropriate—we create a reliable conversion pipeline. This approach saves time, reduces tech headaches, and helps teams focus on high-value conversations rather than repetitive follow-up tasks.

We encourage you to start simple: build one workflow, test it thoroughly, measure outcomes, and iterate. The gains you’ll see in response rates and booked appointments are often immediate.

FAQ

How fast should the initial follow-up be after form submission?

We recommend sending both email and SMS within 1–2 minutes of submission. The faster the response, the higher the likelihood of conversion. Immediate outreach captures attention while interest is fresh.

Should we always use both email and SMS?

Yes—using both channels increases reach. Email provides context and deliverables; SMS prompts quick replies. Combining them gives prospects options for how they prefer to engage.

How do we handle contacts who opt out?

Respect opt-outs immediately. Ensure automations check opt-out and do-not-contact lists before sending messages. Provide a clear opt-out method in every message and honor it without question.

What if a lead replies with a complex question outside the automation’s scope?

Route complex questions to a salesperson or support agent. Use the automation to notify the appropriate team member and tag the lead so you can follow up manually with a personalized response.

How many follow-ups are too many?

There’s no one-size-fits-all, but a good starting cadence is 3–5 touches over 7–10 days (initial email+SMS, follow-up SMS, call/voicemail, final check-in). Monitor complaint rates and unsubscribe counts, and dial back if you see negative signals.

Can we customize the template to match our industry?

Absolutely. Templates are a starting point. We tailor subject lines, message copy, timing, and branching logic to fit specific industries, buyer journeys, and offer complexity.

How do voicemail drops work and are they effective?

Voicemail drops upload a recorded message that’s left on an unanswered call. They’re effective because they combine the authenticity of voice with the efficiency of automation. Keep voicemail short and action-oriented for best results.

How do we measure success?

Track reply rates, booking rates, call connects, voicemails played, and conversion from lead to booked appointment. Use these metrics to identify where the workflow succeeds or needs adjustment.

Who should own this workflow internally?

Marketing should build and monitor the sequence, while sales should own the follow-up conversations. Collaboration is key—regular syncs between teams ensure messaging and handoffs are smooth.

What’s the simplest way to get started?

Choose one high-intent form (for example, "Request a Consultation"), attach a basic workflow that sends immediate email+SMS, waits 48 hours for a reply, and then attempts a call with a voicemail drop if needed. Test it, then expand to other forms and campaigns.

Final Thoughts

We’re committed to practical, no-nonsense automations that make life easier for growing teams. By capturing interest at the moment of intent, personalizing outreach, and using intelligent escalation, we increase the odds of converting leads into customers while keeping our processes simple and scalable.

If you’d like help implementing or customizing these automations for your business, reach out and we’ll guide you through a hands-on setup and testing process tailored to your needs.

Read more